General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsUS Supreme Court Ruled in middle of night, 1-2am, Stopping Trump's flights out of country
https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2025/4/19/2317398/-Wow-Supreme-Court-s-Early-Morning-Order-Stops-Deportation-Flights?
Wow: Supreme Court's Early Morning Order Stops Deportation Flights
by KeithDB
Saturday, April 19, 2025 at 6:10:31a CDT
I wake up to something Ive never heard of before. When I went to bed last night court hearings were blowing up again as the Trump Regime was apparently preparing to send hundreds more to El Salvador. To nominally comply with the Supreme Courts prior order requiring real and effective due process the Regime isolated those targeted and compelled or tricked them into signing statements saying they accepted the deportation.
At a hearing last night a D.C. judge sympathized with desperate lawyers for those to be deported but said he was powerless to stop them under the Supreme Courts decision saying all such appeals had to be made in the district where the government was holding the people. The judge invited the Supreme Court to intervene, but it was already about 9 pm.
Well, I have never heard of this sort of thing before, but the Supreme Court, in the dead of night, did intervene. In an order dated Saturday, so it happened, sometime after Midnight (it appears to have been between 1 or 2 am) the Supreme Court issue an order that all such deportations under the Enemy Aliens Act be stopped. It was a 7-2 decision with Alito and Thomas dissenting. A written dissent by Alito is to follow because he apparently did not have time to write one yet.
Folks, that is some crazy jacked up crazy stuff there from the Supreme Court. Dark of the night full vote orders like that is not anything I have heard of before. Sometimes one assigned justice issues a late night emergency order in rare life or death situations delaying things, but this was a vote of the full court.
The good news is that the Supreme Court stayed up into the wee hours of the morning to preserve the rule of law against autocracy. The bad news is that two dissented.
MarineCombatEngineer
(17,552 posts)What a surprise.
COL Mustard
(7,931 posts)Color me shocked.
Not!
walkingman
(10,260 posts)2 more just like them but younger.
Ocelot II
(128,840 posts)the majority didn't give Alito time to finish his dissent - they just snatched the order away, leaving it to say only that his "statement is pending." Apparently it's still pending; I haven't been able to find it yet.
Tadpole Raisin
(1,889 posts)and hopefully most of the majority is tired of being played with Alitos and Thomass efforts to drag things out for their comrade the Fing convicted Felon!
MadameButterfly
(3,725 posts)A dissent would have found these guys in El Salvadore already.
mountain grammy
(28,623 posts)MichMan
(16,537 posts)to any country? Or just flights?
IrishBubbaLiberal
(2,561 posts)Not sure.
I read somewhere that it was about Texas,
But it might pertain to ALL deportations to another country
Ruling details
BREAKING: The Supreme Court has blocked the Trump administration from deporting foreign nationals under the Alien Enemies Act. Thomas, Alito dissent.
— Kyle Cheney (@kyledcheney.bsky.social) 2025-04-19T05:10:52.614Z
sl8
(16,967 posts)SCOTUS invited the government to come back after the 5th Circuit was finished with the case.
Its a significant blow to the Administration, and a good first step, but only applies to Venezuelans in that district.
IrishBubbaLiberal
(2,561 posts)gab13by13
(31,063 posts)that it isn't needed in a dictatorship? No more bribes, no more trips.
vanlassie
(6,217 posts)OMGWTF
(5,000 posts)SCOTUS risks being irrelevant, as do all other courts of law when the only law of the land is "Whatever T💩p said."
KPN
(17,119 posts)Not Alito and Thomas. But I'll take 7-2 ... even if it's for the less than confidence building reason that your premise is right.
orangecrush
(28,084 posts)Iamscrewed
(486 posts)More of this is overdue. This administration so blatantly ilegal in its actions that it's like 1933 Germany. If they aren't stopped it will only get worse.
Uncle Joe
(64,089 posts)Thanks for the thread IrishBubbaLiberal
Attilatheblond
(8,147 posts)It's obvious he thinks it means he can do ANYTHING and that, since he is POTUS, EVERYTHING he does is covered.
Time to slap him back into reality about LAWS.
Mustellus
(408 posts).. you don't need a Supreme Court if you have a Supreme Ruler.
Hekate
(100,131 posts)Figarosmom
(9,643 posts)They were told to get with the program and alito and thomas obeyed like good little kept men.
IbogaProject
(5,565 posts)Captain Zero
(8,711 posts)Word is that the Pope had some things to say to Vance about treatment of immigrants while he was on his Rome visit.
Vance and the "two" are Catholic.
So are other SC members, like 4-5 more I think. There needs to be a moratorium for Catholics on the SC.
EndlessWire
(8,103 posts)for the information. They must be super pissed that they are being defied by the trump regime?
I wonder if they can see what's happening and regret making him a King. You know, they are on the wrong side of history and will be infamous if they don't stand with us against this dictator.
It's rather fun to picture them in bathrobes instead of judicial robes, perhaps yawning and drinking coffee--or other stuff, as the case may be. I love the idea of secret meetings in the middle of the night in order to thwart dastardly deeds. Or, maybe not so secret, as they must have clerks and such in attendance also?
Great news!
iemanja
(57,314 posts)KPN
(17,119 posts)Tickle
(4,131 posts)IrishBubbaLiberal
(2,561 posts)The Supreme Court has blocked the Trump administration from deporting foreign nationals under the Alien Enemies Act. Thomas, Alito dissent.
From todays Supreme Court ruling:
The government is directed not to remove any member of the punitive class
of detainees from the United States until further order from this court
Key words
any member of the punitive class of detainees
See..
BREAKING: The Supreme Court has blocked the Trump administration from deporting foreign nationals under the Alien Enemies Act. Thomas, Alito dissent.
— Kyle Cheney (@kyledcheney.bsky.social) 2025-04-19T05:10:52.614Z
Frasier Balzov
(4,832 posts)Irish_Dem
(79,401 posts)The jobs they are paid handsomely to do.
live love laugh
(16,172 posts)MadameButterfly
(3,725 posts)the 4 Republicans showing late signs of sanity offer a glimmer of hope for the Republic.
I had only dared hope for Amy Coney Barrett and Roberts when democracy is finally put on the line. Now, maybe more.
jmowreader
(52,870 posts)All three of Trump's appointees, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett, voted against him.
DonCoquixote
(13,939 posts)and be forced to resign
CrispyQ
(40,614 posts)Deportation includes due process. Rendition does not.
Our media is so sloppy with words. The general public is too, but the media shouldn't be.