Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
43 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
So, boots on the ground (Original Post) Aviation Pro 10 hrs ago OP
that's what I say too Skittles 10 hrs ago #1
Post removed Post removed 10 hrs ago #2
I am very curious, and I have been hearing this a lot.... Dan 10 hrs ago #3
Iran has killed Americans for 40 years. They are religious nutcases Melon 10 hrs ago #4
Yep, well we do live in a glass house. Dan 9 hrs ago #6
Iranians kill Americans through their proxies Aviation Pro 9 hrs ago #7
I'm sure that's what countries choie 9 hrs ago #8
It didn't stop the chants of death to America. It didn't Melon 9 hrs ago #10
Trump and those he has surrounded himself with are corrup and incompetent and I suspect their motivations are less than CentralMass 8 hrs ago #12
That's fine. I don't support Trump. Melon 8 hrs ago #14
This administration would f'k up a wet dream. . Kash Patel just aleddgedly fired CentralMass 8 hrs ago #16
👍 agreed. But we are in action so carry it through. Melon 8 hrs ago #18
It's not a legal war. TommyT139 7 hrs ago #39
This is complete utter garbage fujiyamasan 8 hrs ago #22
I'll go watch Fetterman..my preference is not to be Melon 8 hrs ago #24
You may be in the wrong site to be honest fujiyamasan 8 hrs ago #26
I support finishing the job in Iran. Melon 8 hrs ago #28
Do you know that Iran is almost 4 times the size of Iraq? Eko 5 hrs ago #42
Off topic, but your keyboard seems to be on the fritz. summer_in_TX 8 hrs ago #27
I see that and I apologize. Melon 7 hrs ago #30
Np summer_in_TX 7 hrs ago #33
lol you support action directed by Hegseth SamuelTheThird 7 hrs ago #29
Too old...and fucked up at this point. Melon 7 hrs ago #34
So you didn't actually address most of what I typed SamuelTheThird 7 hrs ago #35
I think it will make our country and friend region safer Melon 7 hrs ago #36
Again, didn't address what I typed SamuelTheThird 7 hrs ago #38
You come from a military family? Send your kids or grandkids fujiyamasan 7 hrs ago #40
Whatever. N Korea has killed more Americans than Iran. N Korea HAS the bomb. N Korea HAS an ICBM Cheezoholic 8 hrs ago #13
So...you are wrong. Melon 8 hrs ago #17
" doesn't have a religious mandate to kill Americans. " Intractable 8 hrs ago #19
Then have Bone Saw and his corrupt fucks finish it, leave our kids out of it. The uraniums in the wild by now anyway n/t Cheezoholic 8 hrs ago #21
So this gives trump the right to kill Iran's civilians? C'Mon, you KNOW this isn't about what your speak of. C Moon 4 hrs ago #43
Illegally at war. choie 9 hrs ago #9
There is no "end it for good" Tesha 9 hrs ago #11
Wait, so you support the war if the goal is to end the KPN 8 hrs ago #20
I'm sure enraging millions of Shia Muslims will make us so much safer. I feel safer already, do you? Blues Heron 7 hrs ago #31
WE are the threat. /nt artemisia1 7 hrs ago #41
Send ICE first. All of them. usonian 9 hrs ago #5
Works for me. KPN 8 hrs ago #15
Why spare him? Although I have already seen explanations for why he niyad 8 hrs ago #23
Good to hear this *before* the Senate vote Tasmanian Devil 8 hrs ago #25
They won't go. ChicagoTeamster 7 hrs ago #32
Remote controlled explosives Charmin One 7 hrs ago #37

Response to Aviation Pro (Original post)

Dan

(5,066 posts)
3. I am very curious, and I have been hearing this a lot....
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 10:08 PM
10 hrs ago

Could someone explain to me - the threat that Iran poses to me? Not the threat that it poses to Israel (cause honestly, I don’t care), but to the U.S.?

Melon

(1,390 posts)
4. Iran has killed Americans for 40 years. They are religious nutcases
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 10:12 PM
10 hrs ago

That wake there military up with the chant death to America, death to Israel. They have repeatedly enriched uranium past any industrial use towards the end goal of making a nuclear weapons. Combine nuclear weapon with a mantra of life to kill Americans. If you can’t piece that puzzle together I can’t help you. Once they have a weapon there is no stopping them.

We are now in, so be sure and finish it.

Aviation Pro

(15,457 posts)
7. Iranians kill Americans through their proxies
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 10:42 PM
9 hrs ago

I know of no Iranian forces that have engaged Americans directly with the possible exception of the Qud Forces. The attack on Erbil is an example of how those motherfuckers operate; sucks to be them that they engaged our pipe hitters that day.

choie

(6,856 posts)
8. I'm sure that's what countries
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 10:49 PM
9 hrs ago

have said about us. Including Iran when we overthrew their Prime Minister. We had a peace deal with Iran thanks to Obama. And it was working. Who dismantled that? We did.

Melon

(1,390 posts)
10. It didn't stop the chants of death to America. It didn't
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 11:02 PM
9 hrs ago

Change the mentality. It also likely didn’t change the outcome one.

They were still hiding production. Denying inspections. The teachings of the Imans and the Supreme Leader was the same. The agreement said that their production is checked routinely by an assign agency, not because it’s a great deal, but because we didn’t trust them.

I’m jaded because I worked in the region. Everyone I interacted with did not like or trust Iran. They wanted some kind of military intervention and those conversations were 10 years ago. Oman only had relations with them at the time, but the Omanis didnt trust them either. There government are religious fanatics and will gladly kill you with the belief they will go to paradise.

This war is bringing the rest of the Middle East including Israel together. You cannot like our government but support an action. My view is if we are in with a toe, we need to completed stop the threat forever.

CentralMass

(16,919 posts)
12. Trump and those he has surrounded himself with are corrup and incompetent and I suspect their motivations are less than
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 11:24 PM
8 hrs ago

altruistic..

Melon

(1,390 posts)
14. That's fine. I don't support Trump.
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 11:38 PM
8 hrs ago

But once again I can support an action.
The top guys we see on tv are Trump. They make the final decision. But there are hundreds of individuals …and consultants..that I am positive of…that have been the same across administrations. The same guys under worked under Biden putting together tactics and analysis. It’s a mistake to think the US does anything without a plan. And there are 5 and 10 year scenarios constantly updated about risks to the country.

TommyT139

(2,304 posts)
39. It's not a legal war.
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:42 AM
7 hrs ago

Trump et al could have gone through the legal process, but they didn't, because there is no justification for it.

Even they can't agree on why they supposedly started a war.

fujiyamasan

(1,531 posts)
22. This is complete utter garbage
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:01 AM
8 hrs ago

You’re basically giving the same rationale as Fetterman. Fuck this nonsense.

We heard this shit with Iraq.

You don’t support Trump but you support this “action” just because “plans”.

Suit up or send your kids to go die over there.

Melon

(1,390 posts)
24. I'll go watch Fetterman..my preference is not to be
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:08 AM
8 hrs ago

I know you want every Democratic voter to be the same. But I�d say we are a spectrum. I�ve posted on here regarding some of my background. I assume unlike yourself, I�ve spent considerable time in the Middle East and count as my contacts high level officials in government and business in the region. I�ll be on the phone with contacts in Oman late tonight touching base. You go with your basis in life and I�ll go with mine.

fujiyamasan

(1,531 posts)
26. You may be in the wrong site to be honest
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:12 AM
8 hrs ago

Most of us here don’t want to get involved in another endless war in that god forsaken region.

You still didn’t address anything. More bulllshit about your background. Not sure is that supposed to impress us?

If this is the spectrum for this party, then this country is FUCKED. We have no opposition party then.

Adios.

And fuck Fetterman.

Melon

(1,390 posts)
28. I support finishing the job in Iran.
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:19 AM
8 hrs ago

I really do t care about your view. It sounds like just opposite of anything the republicans do. Which requires zero thought and should be easy for you.
I’m not running for office. I’m a voter and registered Democrat. You hate that there’s anything but the extremes in parties that’s on you. I wasn’t asked to go to war with Iran. We are there so it should be finished. That’s my opinion. I’m not the only one hy the way.

Eko

(9,926 posts)
42. Do you know that Iran is almost 4 times the size of Iraq?
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 03:05 AM
5 hrs ago

Almost 3x the population? Can you explain how you think we will win that? Not that its not possible but I want to hear how you think it would happen.

summer_in_TX

(4,106 posts)
27. Off topic, but your keyboard seems to be on the fritz.
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:15 AM
8 hrs ago

I checked it on my phone too. Same weird characters there.

Melon

(1,390 posts)
30. I see that and I apologize.
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:20 AM
7 hrs ago

I don’t know what’s up. It’s apostrophe’s sometimes.

SamuelTheThird

(860 posts)
29. lol you support action directed by Hegseth
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:19 AM
7 hrs ago

This is fucking ludicrous. You want 100,000s of US troops on the ground in Iran. You going to join up?

Melon

(1,390 posts)
34. Too old...and fucked up at this point.
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:24 AM
7 hrs ago

But…I come from a military family. I don’t take it lightly . I consider finishing this now, while Iran is weak, will be less costly than allowing them to rebuild their weapons stockpiles. Pay now or pay later. As I’ve said, we are there so don’t leave it half done.

SamuelTheThird

(860 posts)
35. So you didn't actually address most of what I typed
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:28 AM
7 hrs ago

By your 'logic', you must have supported the Iraq war as well

Melon

(1,390 posts)
36. I think it will make our country and friend region safer
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:33 AM
7 hrs ago

I think it it hurts China economically a levels the manufacturing economies.
And it cuts off a major supplier of drones to Russia.
As I’ve said, I support finishing what we start.

SamuelTheThird

(860 posts)
38. Again, didn't address what I typed
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:36 AM
7 hrs ago

You expect drunken Hegseth to direct a massive boots on the ground effort. And what about rebuilding?

Russia is manufacturing their own drones.

Are you proposing we take over Iran and refuse to sell oil to China?

You don't run your war policy on cliches, and that's all 'finish what we start' adds to this. No real thought there.

Cheezoholic

(3,658 posts)
13. Whatever. N Korea has killed more Americans than Iran. N Korea HAS the bomb. N Korea HAS an ICBM
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 11:35 PM
8 hrs ago

N Korea's leadership is BATSHIT CRAZIER than Irans and N Korea tells its people death to America EVERY FUCKING DAY!!. Dirty bombs are not hard to make and you could use energy grade uranium to make one. Iran is surrounded by extremely unstable failed states and a bunch of billionaire kings that want to keep their hands clean with the clerics and are sending OUR KIDS TO DIE FOR THEM!! We just let Iran fail even more and there WILL be even crazier radicals move in and challenge them now potentially putting, at a minimum, energy grade uranium in some crazy fucking Mullah's hands. We couldn't straighten Iraq out which is 1/3rd the size of Iran, TO THIS DAY!

The day I see a member of any of the billionaire kings countries put THEIR OWN FUCKING BOOTS on the ground to help will be NEVER!! Do you know why? We claim to want Iran to be a democracy, come on you Iranians, help yourselves. Those fucking monarchies will NEVER allow an Arab Democracy. That spells trouble for their slave owning woman oppressing asses.
Hold THEM responsible. Tell THEM no more F35s unless you put your crazy neighbor in its place. Not one of those billionaire monarchies has done a FUCKING THING for us!!

Who did the largest terrorist attack to the US in it's history? Oh yeah. NOT IRANIANS.

Melon

(1,390 posts)
17. So...you are wrong.
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 11:45 PM
8 hrs ago

Attacking North Korea now creates significant risk to the US. They have a large nuclear arsenal with advanced delivery technology. They pose a significant regional threat with conventional arms to South Korea and Seoul in particular. It would also cause significant regional instability and are within easy arms reach of their largest ally China. There is no comparison. North Korea and their nuclear threat is the best example of why we should take action prior to nuclear development in Iran. North Korea also has a reputation as a Hermit Kingdom if left alone and doesn’t have a religious mandate to kill Americans.

Intractable

(1,927 posts)
19. " doesn't have a religious mandate to kill Americans. "
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 11:50 PM
8 hrs ago

Perhaps. But, the North Korean gov't can be substantially influenced by Putin.

Cheezoholic

(3,658 posts)
21. Then have Bone Saw and his corrupt fucks finish it, leave our kids out of it. The uraniums in the wild by now anyway n/t
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 11:58 PM
8 hrs ago

C Moon

(13,586 posts)
43. So this gives trump the right to kill Iran's civilians? C'Mon, you KNOW this isn't about what your speak of.
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 03:30 AM
4 hrs ago

It's all about trump and billionaires.

choie

(6,856 posts)
9. Illegally at war.
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 10:52 PM
9 hrs ago

Have we received any evidence that we were under threat? No. Trump unilaterally went to war when it's Congress' role to declare war. Just because we despise a leader doesn't give us the right to assassinate him. We are a rogue nation.

Tesha

(21,124 posts)
11. There is no "end it for good"
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 11:16 PM
9 hrs ago

We've learned this over and over and over - even if you drop nukes - a war will not end.

A peace, brokered honestly with the rest of the world supporting, and Netanyahu in jail, is our only hope in the Middle East

KPN

(17,306 posts)
20. Wait, so you support the war if the goal is to end the
Tue Mar 3, 2026, 11:57 PM
8 hrs ago

Iran threat for good. What end result does that completely in your view? What constitutes ending for good? Can you explain? I’m personally having a hard time imagining a “for good” solution.

Blues Heron

(8,604 posts)
31. I'm sure enraging millions of Shia Muslims will make us so much safer. I feel safer already, do you?
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:21 AM
7 hrs ago

niyad

(131,514 posts)
23. Why spare him? Although I have already seen explanations for why he
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:08 AM
8 hrs ago

would be disqualifed from serving.

Tasmanian Devil

(124 posts)
25. Good to hear this *before* the Senate vote
Wed Mar 4, 2026, 12:10 AM
8 hrs ago

Maybe it will change a few votes on the war powers act. Yeah, probably not, but I can hope.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»So, boots on the ground