Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

debm55

(54,145 posts)
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 11:55 AM Sunday

What is/are your favorite Christmas cookies? Mine is kolacky with apricot or nut mixture. What is your's?

82 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What is/are your favorite Christmas cookies? Mine is kolacky with apricot or nut mixture. What is your's? (Original Post) debm55 Sunday OP
I haven't tried that, but would like to. pandr32 Sunday #1
I love your cookie selections, Kolachy are Eastern European cookies, made with a cream cheese dough. Roll it out into debm55 Sunday #3
Sounds amazing! pandr32 Sunday #25
When I was a young girl my Baba made them-I watched her, There was no recipe she made them from. I asked. Every year I debm55 Sunday #26
I agree with the Kolachy exept with cherries in them. OLDMDDEM Yesterday #79
Thank you OLDMDDEM. That sounds great. debm55 Yesterday #82
Gingerbread cookies anciano Sunday #2
Thank you very much for sharing with us, anciano. debm55 Sunday #4
I can't remember what they're called, boonecreek Sunday #5
I remember those. Thank you for sharing boonecreek. I think we just called them Hershey Kiss cookies. I don't know the debm55 Sunday #10
Hersey peanut butter blooms. sinkingfeeling Sunday #11
Thank you for the name, sinkingfeeling.for the name. debm55 Sunday #16
I used to make shortbread cookies as a kid at christmas. applegrove Sunday #6
Thank you very much applegrove. I loved making those decorated sugar cookies.Oh and those silver balls and sprinkles debm55 Sunday #18
We used to always get one of those round tins House of Roberts Sunday #7
Thank you very much, House of Roberts. I remember them --they came in a blue tin. Loved them debm55 Sunday #19
Brandy snaps chowmama Sunday #8
OH wow. Thank you very much for sharing with us, chowmama. They sound delicious. debm55 Sunday #21
A Pennsylvania Dutch delicacy, Sugar Cakes Freddie Sunday #9
Thank you very much Freddie for sharing that with us. We have a Giant Eagle here in SW PA but no Giant. I am going to debm55 Sunday #22
Mexican hot chocolate cookies and peppermint candy cane cookies. sinkingfeeling Sunday #12
Thank you very much for sharing with us, sinkingfeeling. I used to make the pepperment candy cane cookies. I have never debm55 Sunday #23
I have several buzzycrumbhunger Sunday #13
Thank you very much for your selections buzzycrumbhunger. I have made the Russian tea cakes. Agree with the powdered debm55 Sunday #15
Frosted sugar cookies, decorated and sprinkled with sprinkles. Polly Hennessey Sunday #14
Good for you Polly Hennessey. I love your selections. debm55 Sunday #17
This one! justaprogressive Sunday #20
Oh my they look great. and I bet they taste wonderful. Thank you so much for sharing, justaprogressive. Are you trained debm55 Sunday #24
worked justaprogressive Sunday #30
Now we know. Your love of cooking shines through. Polly Hennessey Sunday #32
You are a fantastic and talented person, justaprogressive. debm55 Sunday #36
...💙 justaprogressive Sunday #68
Thanks for photo and recipe. beveeheart Sunday #63
They sure look good😀 malaise Monday #70
Every cookie deb is my favorite. Duncanpup Sunday #27
HAHHAHHAHHAHAH. Thank you for sharing your selections,Duncanpup HAHAHHHAHHAHHAH debm55 Sunday #35
My mom made wonderful toll house cookies. They were my favorite. Borogove Sunday #28
Thank you very much Borogove. I like them fresh out of the oven with a cold glass of milk May the memories of your mom debm55 Sunday #47
Vanilla bean cookies bfoxmatt Sunday #29
HAHHHAHAHA. Thank you very much, bfoxmatt. Your cookies sound so delicious with over the top taste. Thank you for debm55 Sunday #34
Two of my favorites I still make each year. Big Blue Marble Sunday #31
Thank you very much, Big Blue Marble . Your two selections sound wonderful. Enjoy my friend. debm55 Sunday #33
Overwhelmed much? Dear_Prudence Sunday #37
thank you very much. Dear_Prudence. I remember the slice and bake cookies. My very young son enjoyed watching me make debm55 Sunday #39
Dear_Prudence, Diamond_Dog Sunday #65
Wow! Dear_Prudence Sunday #69
Buckeyes CanonRay Sunday #38
Thank you very much CanonRay. Wonderful cookie. They are so good. Enjoy and give Mrs. Canon a big kiss for making them debm55 Sunday #46
Biscochitos from New Mexico! Loisita123 Sunday #40
I use powdered sugar on my Russian tea cakes and I agree with you Loisita123.--it makes a mess. I love debm55 Sunday #45
Snickerdoodles Onthefly Sunday #41
Thank you very much Onthefly. You are so right --easy to make and a wonderful cookie to eat. Enjoy. debm55 Sunday #43
Hard to find, but Delicious! beemerphill Sunday #42
Thank you very much beemerphill for the suggestion. The name sounds familiar. I think I had one-fantastic, but never debm55 Sunday #44
Walkers Shortbread malaise Sunday #48
Thank you so much for sharing with us. malaise. Scottish shortbread. I bet it is good. Thank you debm55 Sunday #49
The more recent one with chocolate chips malaise Sunday #50
I am going to look into that. Thank you very much. debm55 Sunday #59
Here malaise Sunday #62
Thank you very much, malaise. I will see if they have the next time I go to the store. debm55 Monday #72
The ginger ones are also very good. mwmisses4289 Sunday #66
Yes indeed malaise Sunday #67
White Chocolate Macadamia Cookies Emile Sunday #51
Wow. that sounds great. Thank you very much Emile. for sharing with us. debm55 Sunday #55
jelly-topped sugar cookies Eugene Sunday #52
I love those. Thank you so much, Eugene, for sharing those delights with us. Enjoy. debm55 Sunday #58
Date bars. Sneederbunk Sunday #53
YUMMY! Thank you very much Sneederbunk for sharing with us. They sound great. Enjoy. debm55 Sunday #54
My mom made a date bar with beveeheart Sunday #64
Thank you very much beceeheart for sharing. They sound delicious. debm55 Yesterday #75
I like them all! Diamond_Dog Sunday #56
Thank you very much, Check you justaprogressive's post on Sunday cookies. debm55 Sunday #60
Raspberry Thumprint cookies Endlessmike56 Sunday #57
thank you very much Endlessmike56. and may the memories of your mom be a blessing to you. debm55 Sunday #61
Same here! WestMichRad Monday #71
I guess the sugar cookies with the colored crunchy sprinkes covering them.... electric_blue68 Yesterday #73
Thank you very much, electric_blue68 Those cookies are great any time of the year. debm55 Yesterday #76
I think someone mentioned churning butter? electric_blue68 Yesterday #74
Yes, I used to have my class take heavy whipping cream. I would add a little sugar and salt. I then put in a closed debm55 Yesterday #77
Ha! Interesting! electric_blue68 Yesterday #78
The key is heavy whipping cream. debm55 Yesterday #80
Got it! electric_blue68 Yesterday #81

pandr32

(13,705 posts)
1. I haven't tried that, but would like to.
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 11:59 AM
Sunday

I am partial to buttery cookies, peppermint/almond chocolate chip ones, spicy ginger ones, and sugar cookies with candied peel.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
3. I love your cookie selections, Kolachy are Eastern European cookies, made with a cream cheese dough. Roll it out into
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 12:10 PM
Sunday

square, add the nut mixture or apricots preserves in the center and out into the two diagonal sides of the pastry square and then bring the other two diagonal sides together and pinch in the center. I have to look it up every year. as I forget. They are spelled differently but I like the cream cheese dough the best.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
26. When I was a young girl my Baba made them-I watched her, There was no recipe she made them from. I asked. Every year I
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 01:52 PM
Sunday

watched and eventually learned from just watching. I made them for my wedding together with stuffed cabbage and nut rolls and apricot rolls. They were made from watching--never a recipe. I looked on the internet and there are recipes for kolachy. I don't know how to post links. But find the one with cream cheese added to the dough.

boonecreek

(1,346 posts)
5. I can't remember what they're called,
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 12:21 PM
Sunday

but they were sugar cookies with a Hershey's Kiss on top.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
10. I remember those. Thank you for sharing boonecreek. I think we just called them Hershey Kiss cookies. I don't know the
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 12:37 PM
Sunday

real name for them. Enjoy.

applegrove

(129,638 posts)
6. I used to make shortbread cookies as a kid at christmas.
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 12:23 PM
Sunday

Nothing like decorating your own creations with those tiny silver balls and pink sprinkles and then eating them right away.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
18. Thank you very much applegrove. I loved making those decorated sugar cookies.Oh and those silver balls and sprinkles
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 01:29 PM
Sunday

Were great. Thank you for the memories.

House of Roberts

(6,354 posts)
7. We used to always get one of those round tins
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 12:23 PM
Sunday

of Danish butter cookies. I haven't had one of those in a long time though.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
19. Thank you very much, House of Roberts. I remember them --they came in a blue tin. Loved them
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 01:30 PM
Sunday

Freddie

(10,029 posts)
9. A Pennsylvania Dutch delicacy, Sugar Cakes
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 12:27 PM
Sunday
https://www.bigoven.com/recipe/sugar-cakes-pennsylvania-dutch-soft-sugar-cookies/609527

Large soft cookies with a unique not-too-sweet taste thanks to buttermilk (no substitutions!)
Note to my PA friends, do not buy the so-called sugar cakes from the bakery at Giant, they’re awful.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
22. Thank you very much Freddie for sharing that with us. We have a Giant Eagle here in SW PA but no Giant. I am going to
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 01:34 PM
Sunday

your link to check them out.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
23. Thank you very much for sharing with us, sinkingfeeling. I used to make the pepperment candy cane cookies. I have never
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 01:37 PM
Sunday

had the Mexican hot chocolate cookies. They sound great.

buzzycrumbhunger

(1,552 posts)
13. I have several
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 12:50 PM
Sunday

First are what my Gran called Russian teacakes, little balls of dough with pecans or walnuts that you roll in powdered sugar whilst they're still warm. Twice, so they make a mess when you eat them.

I also love mum's sugar crinkles (regular and ginger versions) that you roll into balls and then fine sugar, and they puff up when baking and then flatten out with crinkles on top.

Third fave is straight-on gingerbread, heavy on the blackstrap molasses.

Gingerbread and regular sugar cookies were always a must because rolling them out, cutting into shapes, and then decorating them kept us out of mum's hair for a couple days, but who has time for all that? I'll typically make a couple-three of the first ones and call it good these days. I think I'm too beat by work/life to be the Suzy Homemaker I was when I had young kids to impress. *Shrug*

debm55

(54,145 posts)
15. Thank you very much for your selections buzzycrumbhunger. I have made the Russian tea cakes. Agree with the powdered
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 01:13 PM
Sunday

sugar. I also agree with the having more energy when my son was younger. We would have an open open house preChristmas for friends and teachers and a Christmas party. All food was made by me and I was working and taking care of my son while my husband was traveling for work two weeks a month, every month. Energy level was so high. Not so more.

Polly Hennessey

(8,452 posts)
14. Frosted sugar cookies, decorated and sprinkled with sprinkles.
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 01:09 PM
Sunday

Now for the truth: I will eat any Christmas cookie 🍪 with a cup of hot chocolate and a couple of splashes of peppermint schnapps. 🧑‍🎄🌲

justaprogressive

(6,133 posts)
20. This one!
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 01:31 PM
Sunday




Italian Butter Cookies

Buttery and creamy, with hints of vanilla and almond,
these melt in your mouth morsels are indisputably delicious!

PREP: 20 Minutes
BAKE: 8 Minutes
YIELD: Depends on the cookie press disc used

INGREDIENTS


1 cup unsalted butter
3/4 cup granulated sugar
1 extra large egg
*1 teaspoon almond extract
*1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
Chocolate chips
Sprinkling sugars
Food colors, for tinting, if desired

*Ed. These are large huge quantities!

In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with a paddle
attachment, cream the butter and sugar on medium for five
minutes, until light and fluffy. Scrape down the sides of the
bowl, and with the mixer on low, add the egg, and then the
two extracts.

Sift the flour and the salt together. With the mixer on
low, add the flour mixture to the butter mixture slowly,
scraping down the sides of the bowl several times, until a
soft dough forms.

If you wish to divide the dough and use tints, you may do
so at this point. Fit a cookie press with your desired tip, and
with one chocolate chip pressed into the center. The dough
press is best when slightly chilled but not hard. If using
sprinkling sugars, decorate at will. Press the cookies about
two inches apart onto the parchment lined sheets and chill
the cookies for fifteen minutes.

Preheat the oven to 375° F. Place one oven rack in the center
of the oven. Bake the cookies one tray at a time in the center
of the oven for eight minutes, rotating the baking sheet
halfway through. Watch the cookies closely; they should
not brown but remain pale and soft.

Remove the baking sheets to wire cooling racks and cool
for ten minutes; remove the cookies to cooling racks to cool
completely. Store the cookies in the refrigerator in a very
airtight container between layers of waxed paper. Allow the
cookies to come to room temperature before serving

NOTES:

Butter cookies are very delicate; they absorb strong aromas.
When baking, I make sure the ovenis very clean. When
cooling the cookies, I make sure there is nothing else out in the
kitchen. I only store in very clean plastic containers, or fresh
new resealable bags. I don’t usually tint my cookies; I leave
them plain. When using a cookie press with a tip, I prefer to
use the floret or the daisy for a classic look.

From "The Cookie King"
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/29996003-the-cookie-king

debm55

(54,145 posts)
24. Oh my they look great. and I bet they taste wonderful. Thank you so much for sharing, justaprogressive. Are you trained
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 01:40 PM
Sunday

in cooking or self taught? You are a wonder in the kitchen.

justaprogressive

(6,133 posts)
30. worked
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 02:30 PM
Sunday

in kitchens on and off, (interspersed between music and nursing)
Uhh prep, line cook, dishwasher, pastry cook culminating as a private chef fixing
lunches for ~30 people 5x a week

debm55

(54,145 posts)
47. Thank you very much Borogove. I like them fresh out of the oven with a cold glass of milk May the memories of your mom
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 05:37 PM
Sunday

be a blessing to you.

bfoxmatt

(38 posts)
29. Vanilla bean cookies
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 02:08 PM
Sunday

AKA wedding cookies/nutty fingers -- those rolled in confectioner's sugar after they bake, but chop up one entire vanilla bean in the confectioner's sugar. Takes the flavor over the top! Second favorite -- double chocolate cherry cookies. You're making me want to start baking!

debm55

(54,145 posts)
34. HAHHHAHAHA. Thank you very much, bfoxmatt. Your cookies sound so delicious with over the top taste. Thank you for
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 02:53 PM
Sunday

sharing your selections. and enjoy.

Big Blue Marble

(5,661 posts)
31. Two of my favorites I still make each year.
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 02:34 PM
Sunday

Santa's Whiskers a shortbread cookie made with pecans and candied cherries, red and green then
rolled in coconut.

Chocolate Mosaics nut fudge wrapped in a brown sugar dough.

My mother made kolackies. I adored them. She made the apricot and cream cheese filling as
well as my favorite, cherry filling.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
33. Thank you very much, Big Blue Marble . Your two selections sound wonderful. Enjoy my friend.
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 02:49 PM
Sunday

Dear_Prudence

(988 posts)
37. Overwhelmed much?
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 03:47 PM
Sunday

When my son and daughter were in high school, a couple decades ago, I was just worn out from making all the different kinds of Christmas cookies. So I asked them what their favorite cookie was, hoping to cut back on the kinds of cookies. They both said their favorite was those cookies with the snowman shape inside. Yup, they loved the slice and bake sugar cookies, the ones in the tube, with the snowman or Xmas tree food-dye painting inside. That took me down a peg as an imagined wonderful baker! But it did simplify cookie making! So, take it easy!

debm55

(54,145 posts)
39. thank you very much. Dear_Prudence. I remember the slice and bake cookies. My very young son enjoyed watching me make
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 04:16 PM
Sunday

(slice) them

Diamond_Dog

(39,514 posts)
65. Dear_Prudence,
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 06:34 PM
Sunday

I can relate. I used to knock myself out making all different kinds of cookies for Christmas when my boys were small. At least 8 or 10 different kinds. I had so many I gave them away as gifts too. Everyone seemed to like them. One time my husband (who isn’t really into sweets anyway) took one look at my cookie tray and said, “You never make anything I like”.



debm55

(54,145 posts)
46. Thank you very much CanonRay. Wonderful cookie. They are so good. Enjoy and give Mrs. Canon a big kiss for making them
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 05:35 PM
Sunday

Loisita123

(2 posts)
40. Biscochitos from New Mexico!
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 04:30 PM
Sunday

Having fun baking tons of biscochitos for family and friends. Also love rugalach and Mexican wedding cookies, with powdered sugar icing mixed with triple sec, avoid that powdered sugar mess

debm55

(54,145 posts)
45. I use powdered sugar on my Russian tea cakes and I agree with you Loisita123.--it makes a mess. I love
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 05:33 PM
Sunday

almond biscochito with a cup of tea.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
43. Thank you very much Onthefly. You are so right --easy to make and a wonderful cookie to eat. Enjoy.
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 05:18 PM
Sunday

beemerphill

(598 posts)
42. Hard to find, but Delicious!
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 05:18 PM
Sunday

They are called Fruit Drop Cookies, and there are many ingredients; they are not cheap to make, and require a friend who likes to take a lot of time cooking. If you can find someone who covers all the bases, you will have one of the Finest Christmas Cookies ever. Have fun, it makes a Large Batch.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
44. Thank you very much beemerphill for the suggestion. The name sounds familiar. I think I had one-fantastic, but never
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 05:22 PM
Sunday

made one. Thank you again.

malaise

(291,777 posts)
48. Walkers Shortbread
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 05:45 PM
Sunday

You knew it was Christmas at our home and paternal granny’s when that big tin of Walkers showed up.
Now it’s available in small packets

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DR6yv5UCNg3/

debm55

(54,145 posts)
49. Thank you so much for sharing with us. malaise. Scottish shortbread. I bet it is good. Thank you
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 05:49 PM
Sunday

malaise

(291,777 posts)
62. Here
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 06:27 PM
Sunday

I only serve it as part of dessert for the one dinner for friends and family that I cook for the season.
You can find it in more than a few US supermarkets
https://us.walkersshortbread.com/chocolate-chip-shortbread-4-4-oz/

debm55

(54,145 posts)
72. Thank you very much, malaise. I will see if they have the next time I go to the store.
Mon Dec 8, 2025, 10:13 AM
Monday

beveeheart

(1,511 posts)
64. My mom made a date bar with
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 06:34 PM
Sunday

shredded coconut, sweetened condensed milk and pecans. I loved them.

Diamond_Dog

(39,514 posts)
56. I like them all!
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 06:07 PM
Sunday

In years past I used to start in October and make dozens of Christmas cookies for my family and to give away as gifts. Mostly when my boys were children. I just don’t have it in me anymore. I make several kinds now and that’s it. My husband isn’t into sweets so if they’re in the house I end up eating them - I love cookies but I don’t need to be eating so many! Last couple years I ordered a tray of baklava from a local Mediterranean deli for Christmas and everyone seemed to like that just as much as the homemade cookies I used to slave over.

I always did like to make Russian teacakes, peanut butter blossoms, and chocolate fudge. My fudge recipe is the same one we learned in 7th grade cooking class! Your Kolachi too.

WestMichRad

(2,864 posts)
71. Same here!
Mon Dec 8, 2025, 09:32 AM
Monday

They were coated with crushed walnuts, and each cookie had a dab of homemade raspberry jam atop. Awesomely delicious!

electric_blue68

(25,376 posts)
73. I guess the sugar cookies with the colored crunchy sprinkes covering them....
Tue Dec 9, 2025, 02:21 AM
Yesterday

At my cousin's her daughter from late teens onward so I would have been in my ?later 30s - she always made very tasty chocolate chips cookies.
So while I don't really think of them as Xmas cookies I had them at Christmas time for decades.

electric_blue68

(25,376 posts)
74. I think someone mentioned churning butter?
Tue Dec 9, 2025, 12:01 PM
Yesterday

I had no idea that whipped heavy cream could become butter!

So I looked it up. The churning motions break up the protein, and fats that are originally together. The fat cells clump together, and become butter, while the liquid, and most protein run off.

debm55

(54,145 posts)
77. Yes, I used to have my class take heavy whipping cream. I would add a little sugar and salt. I then put in a closed
Tue Dec 9, 2025, 12:24 PM
Yesterday

plastic container and pass it around the room . Each child would shake up and down 20 times. I would occasionally check it . Most it would become butter by the time the last student got it. Would serve the class their 'churned" butter with cornbread.

electric_blue68

(25,376 posts)
81. Got it!
Tue Dec 9, 2025, 12:46 PM
Yesterday

I might try it at some future time. 😄
Get a small container of heavy whipped cream, right? And will buy a few rolls.

If i do, I'll let you know! 😄👍

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What is/are your favorite...