Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Ponietz

(3,953 posts)
27. Interesting -- the biggest threat to Netanyahu's government are the ultra orthodox Haredi
Thu Jun 19, 2025, 07:57 AM
Jun 19

The Haredi, ultra-orthodox religious yeshiva students, have been exempt from the military draft since Israel’s inception, but no longer. The rabbis threaten to dissolve the Knesset unless the exemption is reinstated. This is paywalled but I read it on https://archive.ph.

Israel's Haredi Draft Crisis: Why Netanyahu's Coalition Is on the Brink of Collapse, and What Could Happen Next
https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2025-06-05/ty-article/.premium/israels-haredi-draft-crisis-why-netanyahus-coalition-is-on-the-brink-of-collapse/00000197-40b9-de48-a1f7-f5bf066e0000

Several bills to dissolve the Knesset have already been put on the table, with Yesh Atid, Yisrael Beiteinu and Labor already rushing Thursday morning to volunteer to bring them to the plenum next week. These proceedings will be handled like any other private bill, requiring four votes, with the first vote expected as early as Wednesday.

The Knesset's summer session is set to end in late July, followed by a summer recess until the High Holy Days. Haredi parties may push a bill to dissolve the Knesset through a first vote, then block its progress ahead of the break - using it as an effective threat in negotiations, without actually bringing down the coalition.

The coalition currently includes 68 seats, meaning UTJ's seven MKs alone cannot dissolve the Knesset or topple the government without Shas. If UTJ were to leave the coalition on its own, the coalition would still have a one-seat majority - and it is possible that UTJ MKs would continue to support the coalition from the outside.

In addition, Haredi ministers and deputy ministers could resign from the government without leaving the coalition, allowing the Knesset to go on functioning as usual. A recent example of that occurred when Otzma Yehudit left the government for a few months following the hostage deal, leaving its functionaries in key positions in various government ministries, only to return to the government's fold later on.



Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Regime Change Needed in Israel [View all] Bread and Circuses Jun 18 OP
Wow RandySF Jun 18 #1
Netanyahu is like Trump Easterncedar Jun 18 #2
You nailed it. Bread and Circuses Jun 18 #6
Yup DENVERPOPS Jun 18 #20
Regime chsnge Fiddlelady11 Jun 18 #3
That, too. yorkster Jun 18 #4
I too have always supported the right of Israel to exist ... Intractable Jun 18 #5
Exactly. Sadly, unfortunately Israel has gone down a path of destruction Bread and Circuses Jun 18 #7
none of this is about borders. mopinko Jun 18 #11
Let me explain Bread and Circuses Jun 18 #14
they've been targets of extremists from day 1. mopinko Jun 18 #15
The west has supported Israel...with billions and still does Bread and Circuses Jun 19 #22
It seems ForgedCrank Jun 18 #19
I disagree Bread and Circuses Jun 19 #23
Actually Mountainguy Jun 20 #40
Wall enid602 Jun 19 #36
everything about this 'seems' mopinko Jun 19 #37
Post removed Post removed Jun 18 #8
the palestinians have rejected a 2 state solution since yasar arafat. mopinko Jun 18 #9
Israel has rejected two-state solution twice. Bread and Circuses Jun 18 #16
NONSENSE! It's based upon the actions of their government--- Jack Valentino Jun 18 #13
Thank you for your thoughts Bread and Circuses Jun 18 #17
Their gov't has certainly demonstrated that they have no respect for our opinions, Jack Valentino Jun 18 #21
Yes! Bread and Circuses Jun 19 #24
Poor Iran. Who speaks for the freedom fighters? nt LexVegas Jun 18 #10
i'm tired of trying to discuss this here, but u r just wrong on the facts. mopinko Jun 18 #12
I've been a donor to The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) for years.... Bread and Circuses Jun 18 #18
Once upon a time... roamer65 Jun 19 #25
Iran OC375 Jun 19 #26
Like Iraq? Butterflylady Jun 19 #28
Like USA? OC375 Jun 19 #34
Interesting -- the biggest threat to Netanyahu's government are the ultra orthodox Haredi Ponietz Jun 19 #27
Isn't this the faction that's very militant and pro war but don't have to serve? ms liberty Jun 19 #29
Perhaps the opposite--I've read that some Haredi oppose a political State of Israel because the Messiah hasn't come yet Ponietz Jun 19 #31
Thanks. I know there is one faction like that but I'm not sure what they're known as. ms liberty Jun 19 #32
Thanks, I've read about this Bread and Circuses Jun 20 #38
Agreed. no_hypocrisy Jun 19 #30
Agree Bread and Circuses Jun 20 #39
Four regime changes needed. usonian Jun 19 #33
👍 claudette Jun 19 #35
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Regime Change Needed in I...»Reply #27