General Discussion

LetMyPeopleVote

(168,790 posts)

166. MaddowBlog-Trump's new plan to 'take over' Gaza condemned as 'deranged'

Reply to Eliot Rosewater (Original post)

Sun Aug 24, 2025, 03:44 PM

Sunday

The president didn’t need yet another avoidable international incident. With his radical plan to "own" the Gaza Strip, he managed to create one anyway.

As Trump announces a plan to "own" Gaza, and possibly deploy troops to achieve his goal, spare a thought for those voters who took seriously the idea that the Republican was the candidate of foreign policy restraint. www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddo...
— Steve Benen (@stevebenen.com) 2025-02-05T14:03:55.704Z

https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/trump-gaza-takeover-netanyahu-condemned-rcna190762

On the contrary, earlier in the week, Trump abandoned decades of bipartisan U.S. foreign policy and publicly declared his belief that Palestinians should leave the Gaza Strip to “clean out” the enclave. The Washington Post’s David Ignatius noted soon after that the American president’s comments “astonished moderate Arab leaders who had been looking forward to working with him.”

A week later, as NBC News reported, the Republican went much further down the same radical path:

President Donald Trump, speaking at a White House news conference Tuesday with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, announced that the U.S. would seek ownership of the war-torn Gaza Strip after saying Palestinians have no choice but to leave their homes there. “We’ll own it,” Trump said of Gaza.

The Republican, at the same press conference, described his vision of the United States maintaining a “long-term ownership position” of Gaza......

Trump was also asked at the same press conference whether he has the legal authority to take a sovereign territory. He never quite got around to answering the question.

Link to tweet

The president might’ve struggled with this point because, according to experts in international law, his plan is illegal.

The reactions on Capitol Hill were far from positive. Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina was willing to go out on a limb and call Trump’s plan “problematic,” but Democratic Sen. Tim Kaine of Virginia was far more direct, describing the proposal as “deranged” and “nuts.”

trump and Bibi are still looking for a place to deport all residents of Gaza. I wonder how these voters feel about this plan

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Cha SunSeeker

172 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

I wonder how the "can't vote for Kamala because of Gaza" folks are feeling now [View all] Eliot Rosewater Friday OP

I hope they feel like sh*t, because I do. At some point US voters will realize walkingman Friday #1

I wonder how that POS Jill Stein feels. Initech Friday #6

I and certain she is having a great time mercuryblues Friday #7

If she's smart fujiyamasan Saturday #90

She takes money from Putin, whether she's an actual spy or not ... I don't know FakeNoose Friday #8

Probably like Benny Johnson and Ben Shapiro - they get paid on the DL. Initech Friday #9

Pootie has money to burn FakeNoose Friday #14

Benny Johnson is the unlucky one? He has been rewarded with his own news blog site travelingthrulife Saturday #108

He and Tim Pool both got caught for being paid by RT. Initech Saturday #114

Which is why he started in the US with gun nuts and religious kooks not fooled Saturday #131

Actually- she posts mostly about genocide in Gaza womanofthehills Friday #17

How many times has Jill Stein called for Hamas to immediately surrender so the war will end? SunSeeker Friday #38

Netanyahu wants that ocean front no matter who surrenders womanofthehills Friday #50

Bullshit. Hamas could negotiate the terms of their surrender. Hamas refuses. SunSeeker Friday #69

Fuck her Hornedfrog2000 Friday #66

But no problem with what's happening in Ukraine NoRethugFriends Friday #79

She is an execrable piece of shit greenman3610 Saturday #133

Our politicians can be bought on the cheap. CanonRay Friday #52

I wonder how the people who donated to her fake recount in 2016 feel MichMan Friday #77

I don't think I can say what I hope they feel, for fear of saying something too nasty. dem4decades Friday #2

I'm not sure they weren't a media creation FHRRK Friday #3

Netanyahu Gambled on a Trump Presidency. Will It Pay Off? LetMyPeopleVote Friday #4

Using Gaza as an excuse it's so fucking stupid I can't get over it Eliot Rosewater Friday #5

If Kamala had spoken more about peace she would have easily won womanofthehills Friday #20

No, she wouldn't have "easily won" crimycarny Friday #23

I refuse to respond to that person you're responding to. Eliot Rosewater Friday #31

I wash my hands of it JustAnotherGen Friday #53

Truth hurts. nt RandiFan1290 Saturday #98

On Edit JustAnotherGen Saturday #100

Off topic (sorry), but your post gave me a real question that'd I'd never thought to ask before BlueSpot Friday #71

Impossible populist promises like "I'll bring peace to the Middle East!" "I'll bring back all the manufacturing jobs!" betsuni Saturday #92

Ridiculous mcar Friday #46

Sometimes i wonder which ones are the russians Hornedfrog2000 Friday #67

Anyone know any synonyms for transparent? NoRethugFriends Saturday #80

Is Netanyahu secretly in cahoots with Putin? I guess we'll never know, but it sure looks like it FakeNoose Friday #10

Ya, both Netenyahu and the leaders of Hezbollah and Hamas have Moscow ties... haele Friday #35

If those people were of Palestinian heritage... ShadesOfBlue Friday #11

Not really - walkingman Friday #15

Dems are held to a higher standard because we're promoting problem solving haele Friday #42

So they didn't vote, or voted for the party of no standards --the GOP. Makes no sense. SunSeeker Friday #73

.. jfz9580m Friday #48

We live in the USA, not the Middle East. We are subjected to the rule of Trump. Everyone who lives here is! LeftInTX Friday #58

Good point!! Probably because under Trump they know they might be sent to the Gulag. walkingman Saturday #85

Not protesting because no funding/being told what to do. Dark money and leadership. You know, "grassroots." betsuni Saturday #94

+ 1000 AloeVera Saturday #101

They were mostly white, Latino, ME and Asian. LeftInTX Saturday #123

NOPE Skittles Saturday #142

I assume, unless they were personally and directly impacted, that their attitude is unchanged. IOW BootinUp Friday #12

When I saw Trump call himself and Netanyahu "war heroes" yesterday, my first thought was... W_HAMILTON Friday #13

I thought of Tulsi Gabbard calling Hillary "Queen of the Warmongers," but war is fun now! heroes! betsuni Saturday #95

They are busy blaming Democrats for not stopping Trump Nixie Saturday #99

I had a good friend who voted for Jill Stein. Grumpy Old Guy Friday #16

Prob the same as the people that wouldn't let the Palestinian Dem officials speak at the DNC. Eko Friday #18

Probbably not. SunSeeker Friday #39

I mean your probably right. Eko Friday #45

Right, if only we had let them get on stage and accuse Kamala of supporting genocide! SunSeeker Friday #51

But of course that was not what they were going to do. Eko Friday #54

Why should the "Uncommited" movement spokespeople get precious time at the DNC? SunSeeker Friday #62

So there weren't massacres in Gaza? Eko Friday #68

It is a LIE to suggest Biden was not trying to stop the killing in Gaza. SunSeeker Friday #72

Their people were/are dying. Eko Friday #75

Biden tried repeatedly to get a ceasefire. SunSeeker Saturday #83

We can all tell ourselves nice bedtime stories. AloeVera Saturday #130

He did not end it, he paused it and resumed it. Eko Saturday #155

Ummm, that's untrue. Some Americans did have family members KPN Saturday #136

I was being sarcastic. Eko Saturday #154

Oh, hell. And here I thought you were being an KPN Sunday #158

Fuck 'em. They are beneath contempt. Unforgivable. Oopsie Daisy Friday #19

Political purists like the Bernie Bros didn't help either. ananda Friday #21

I've never ever considered voting for a Republican in my life DSandra Friday #29

Bernie pleaded for his supporters to vote for Kamala DSandra Friday #32

Prophetic. usonian Friday #57

Thanks for posting this, excerpt from the transcript ... cliffside Friday #64

Good for Bernie. Did Kamala say this too? AloeVera Saturday #156

That was such a needless straw man. LisaM Friday #22

Well, there WERE close to 50,000 dead Palestinians... AloeVera Saturday #143

No. But it was a straw man for the election. LisaM Saturday #157

It doesn't work like that. AloeVera Sunday #159

Yes it was. The history and facts are well known. Blaming Democrats is disinformation, lies used to betsuni Sunday #160

Sad but true marti Friday #24

They value Palestinians more than Americans DSandra Friday #25

Netanyahu and Putin are still playing them. nt SunSeeker Friday #36

That was never many people quakerboy Friday #26

Last I checked, they spend very little time mentioning Trump. SunSeeker Friday #43

What made a huge difference was social media womanofthehills Saturday #115

Lets refight old wars. Buzz cook Friday #27

Mostly dead! And Eisenhower wasn't Trump. LeftInTX Friday #56

Just about the falsest of false equivalencies NoRethugFriends Saturday #81

I wasn't even born! LeftInTX Saturday #148

Keep bringing it up wryter2000 Friday #28

I wonder how Harris and her advisors feel about not distancing herself from Biden, Ms. Toad Friday #30

+1 leftstreet Friday #37

Post removed Post removed Friday #44

How else would you categorize the continual focus on wall street economy, Ms. Toad Friday #55

I don't know who the fuck you were listening to, she was NOT "focused on the Wall Street economy." SunSeeker Friday #61

You need to take a chill pill, Ms. Toad Friday #78

How about you "take a chill pill" and go back and listen to what Harris said? SunSeeker Saturday #82

I have both listened to what she said Ms. Toad Saturday #87

I am not "sticking fingers in my ears." I am calling out lies. SunSeeker Saturday #89

1. They aren't lies. Ms. Toad Saturday #112

The almost militant response to anyone disagreeing is not the way to get people on your side crimycarny Saturday #140

I agree with you. Harris talked about all those things. LisaM Wednesday #170

lol, "the continual focus on wall street economy" PunkinPi Saturday #93

Truth be told at last JustAnotherGen Sunday #164

You're correct on all counts, JAG... PunkinPi Monday #169

What's a "Wall Street economy"? betsuni Saturday #113

When Biden (and Harris through most of her campaign) talk about how good the economy is, Ms. Toad Saturday #117

"failing to shift from 401K economy to paycheck economy"? mcar Saturday #110

Honestly dumber than MAGA D_Master81 Friday #33

What is several of your family members had been killed? iemanja Friday #74

Thousands of Israelis were slaughtered, raped, and kidnapped on Oct 6 mcar Saturday #105

Probably because in light of 2 million iemanja Saturday #119

there was tremendous outrage and sympathy Skittles Saturday #147

And what if several of YOUR family members were killed in GAZA? Jilly_in_VA Saturday #106

Why don't you explain the difference iemanja Saturday #118

Right now Jilly_in_VA Saturday #126

Seems like you are responding to a different thread. nt iemanja Saturday #127

Nope Jilly_in_VA Saturday #129

yes, it is dumb Skittles Saturday #144

How do you suppose it feels iemanja Saturday #145

WHAT IF!!! WHAT ABOUT!!!!!! Skittles Saturday #146

And it will never end JustAnotherGen Sunday #163

Amen. Six117 Friday #34

You mean, how are the people who B.See Friday #40

Of course! They're still blaming Democrats! SunSeeker Friday #47

Too bad they failed to realize B.See Friday #49

6+ mil Democrats didn't vote Harris because Gaza? leftstreet Friday #41

Experts say 121,000 votes in 3 swing states (MI, PA & WI) were key in Harris' defeat. SunSeeker Friday #59

Just one of many reasons voters didn't turn out. Some not good on principle, including racism, misogyism, etc. marble falls Friday #76

This irritates me iemanja Friday #60

No, it absolutely shows understanding of history. SunSeeker Friday #65

Palestinians in Gaza were urging U.S. voters to vote for Kamala. PunkinPi Saturday #96

Post removed Post removed Friday #63

Post removed Post removed Friday #70

Just before the DNC in August- 40,000 Palestinian lives lost in Gaza: UN Human Rights Chief pleads for end to fighting cliffside Saturday #84

Biden repeatedly tried to get a ceasefire. Hamas refused to lay down its arms. SunSeeker Saturday #88

I hope they love getting their faces eaten by leopards sakabatou Saturday #86

DNC should have made ads with Gaza carnage and blamed it on Trump. LeftInTX Saturday #91

Post removed Post removed Saturday #97

"you guys" wow, such a clueless comment. The purity mongers Nixie Saturday #102

This message was self-deleted by its author Submariner Saturday #103

It sucks when a member of your family did this cltap Saturday #104

I bet they feel smug Bobstandard Saturday #107

They were positively gleeful... PunkinPi Saturday #111

Pretty sure I just read an article about them protesting Democrats for what travelingthrulife Saturday #109

They were recently protesting Republicans too iemanja Saturday #121

i was aginist her stance on Gaza. Ir was one of those "lesser of two evils" moments. I voted for her. Ping Tung Saturday #116

Last convo with an old friend regarding her not voting for Hillary: "she knows where the levers of power are" and... Hekate Saturday #120

Ha, knowing where the levers of power are. Hillary untrustworthy, the TPP Obama's diabolical plot to screw U.S. workers betsuni Saturday #132

I know someone who still insists that the parties are no different from each other Quanto Magnus Saturday #122

They feel just fine because they were GOP posing as liberals the whole time. DiamondShark Saturday #124

I condemn what happened on Oct 7. I am sickened daily by what my country is facilitating in Gaza. mjvpi Saturday #125

Hard but simple truths. Yet STILL ignored. AloeVera Saturday #152

One of the growing list of things that we need to do as a nation to get our soul back. mjvpi Sunday #161

I confess I didn't vote for Hillary in 2016, but not because I disagreed with 2 percent of her positions. generalbetrayus Saturday #128

Ignored Mysterian Saturday #134

Guilty, I hope. For contributing ... Dave says Saturday #135

Same ones who refuse to read instructions before assembling a purchase -- Big DIY and Establishment IKEA betsuni Saturday #137

I know a couple of them. cab67 Saturday #138

I think many of them were just looking for an excuse ThoughtCriminal Saturday #139

"even though the election was rigged," red dog 1 Saturday #141

Scapegoating is the easy way out. AloeVera Saturday #149

That's not why they didn't vote for her. Iggo Saturday #150

I've seen a few of them. The founder of Muslims for Trump is one example rpannier Saturday #151

If... myohmy2 Saturday #153

Trump-backing Muslim voters finally realize they 'made a big mistake': expert LetMyPeopleVote Sunday #162

Many so very boo hoo angry at mommy and daddy Democrats. betsuni Sunday #165

"Trump-backing Muslim voters finally realize they 'made a big mistake'" Cha Sunday #167

MaddowBlog-Trump's new plan to 'take over' Gaza condemned as 'deranged' LetMyPeopleVote Sunday #166

They Were WARNED!! Cha Sunday #168

US announces it is 'denying and revoking visas' for Palestinian officials ahead of UN General Assembly LetMyPeopleVote 8 hrs ago #171

But one person wasn't allowed to give a speech at the DNC so there was, like, no choice, you know, morally. betsuni 7 hrs ago #172