Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(37,782 posts)
33. Renewables? Really?
Sun Mar 1, 2026, 04:16 PM
Sunday

Um, there is absolutely no evidence, none, that so called "renewables" have anything to do with the use of fossil fuels. The expenditure of trillions of dollars on so called "renewable energy" has had no effect, whatsoever, on the use of dangerous fossil fuels.

In fact, "renewable energy" is dependent on fossil fuels. It is widely reported that the sun is not available 24 hours a day, nor does the wind always blow.

The Chinese are making an effort to displace their coal dependence, but it is with nuclear energy, not renewables. Nuclear energy is reliable, something so called "renewables" are not.

I would certainly advise anyone buying into the "renewables will save us" Kool-Aid, to read this excellent, new book on the topic:

The Elements of Power

Subtitle:

A Story of War, Technology, and the Dirtiest Supply Chain on Earth


...By Nicolas Niarchos

I'm reading it right now, although I have long understood that so called "renewable energy" is not renewable, nor has it ever been about displacing fossil fuels, on which it depends. It was always about attacking the last best chance humanity had at eliminating fossil fuels, nuclear energy.

I personally believe that Chinese support for so called "renewable energy" is to support the rather dirty lanthanide mines in Baotou.




Recommendations

4 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

What are "oil prudes" flamingdem Sunday #1
Thank you. I edited. Melon Sunday #2
Oil Prudes are easily shocked by matters relating to sex or nudity. IronLionZion Sunday #39
Poor oil prudes. So puritannical flamingdem Yesterday #49
OIl Prudes live a repressed joyless life IronLionZion Yesterday #50
So we're pushing China to step up their shift away feom oil. 3_Limes Sunday #3
There is no pushing. China will pursue renewables Melon Sunday #9
Good point! 3_Limes Sunday #20
Renewables? Really? NNadir Sunday #33
Just saw this. Absolutely correct. Melon Sunday #44
So called "renewables" can't help. NNadir Sunday #46
Ok. I think of things more in line to the scale of the issue. Melon Sunday #47
Can you tell me KT2000 Sunday #4
Iran is lashing out at what they can hit. Melon Sunday #10
thank you KT2000 Sunday #21
Giving them way too much credit... lame54 Sunday #5
Putin is not irrational and he runs Trump. yardwork Sunday #38
Interesting - thanks for sharing. Dan Sunday #6
China will continue to buy oil. Melon Sunday #13
I think you're missing the bigger issue pcdb Sunday #25
Ok. So that would just further weaken the BRICS Melon Sunday #27
Do you think the trumpers are aware of this card cachukis Sunday #7
I don't know about common trumpets. Melon Sunday #15
So then, if China has to pay more for oil, and they cachukis Sunday #22
I'm not sure if you are American or itger Melon Sunday #24
Thanks. Great perspective. cachukis Sunday #48
Been thinking overnight about your response that cachukis Yesterday #53
This just brings some rationing in China. Frasier Balzov Sunday #8
There is no rationing. Oil is plentiful right now. Melon Sunday #16
I don't see any of his actions helping us against China. Quite the opposite in fact. Jbraybarten Sunday #11
I don't see it either...they want an excuse is all. There are no excuses that can suffice. Demsrule86 Sunday #14
It absolutely does. Melon Sunday #18
You don't have to be limited to one finger. You could speak your posts into your phone/tablet.... Sogo Sunday #29
Ohhhh. I...need to learn obviously. Melon Sunday #30
Are you defending this? Trump has now killed Americans soldiers...no excuse. Demsrule86 Sunday #12
I am communicating data. I am sharing my market Melon Sunday #19
FFS malaise Sunday #17
Plus...it may not be advisable to credit TSF and this WH with multi-dimensional thinking of future wiggs Sunday #23
I turned them all off malaise Sunday #26
And the only reason the US did this was because Netanyahu knows how to manipulate Trump.... Sogo Sunday #31
Dig up Kushner's ex con daddy and Bibi malaise Sunday #32
Melon, you tried to share your expertise. 1WorldHope Sunday #28
It's not an argument situation. Is my view. Melon Sunday #35
Sounds like a description of how crime families operate. wnylib Sunday #34
In other words - It's easier to BULLY than to compete. nt Exp Sunday #36
Do you actually believe Trump and his clown car can think that deeply or that far ahead? paleotn Sunday #37
This message was self-deleted by its author Melon Sunday #40
I'm not sure what you think is simplistic? Melon Sunday #41
If oil prices rise, somebody will make more money -- so maybe it's a grift too! struggle4progress Sunday #42
Oil prices rising and staying right now is likely bad Melon Sunday #45
This makes a lot of sense. Putin runs Trump. yardwork Sunday #43
I appreciate your perspective. Thanks for posting Easterncedar Yesterday #51
Oil is not "infrastructure" GreatGazoo Yesterday #52
My simplistic take on this maxrandb Yesterday #54
You are speaing as though they have a plan. Ferrets are Cool Yesterday #55
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»It's not about just Iran»Reply #33