The DU Lounge

Fiendish Thingy

(22,985 posts)

9. Maybe for the Best Actor award

Sun Mar 15, 2026, 12:41 PM

Sunday

But there are far more egregious errors in the Best Picture category.

https://britbrief.co.uk/politics/diplomacy/10-most-questionable-oscar-best-picture-winners-ever.html

I would add to that list:
The English Patient
No Country For Old Men (there are far more deserving Coen bros films)

From your list, Hoffman and Voight went on to win Oscars - they were both brand new stars at the time of Wayne’s win (and I think he had cancer at the time).

I think it is a travesty that no Wes Anderson film has ever won a best picture Oscar- at least three- Royal Tennenbaums, Moonrise Kingdom, and Budapest Hotel, are deserving.

Further travesties in the lack of Oscars for Greta Gerwig, Saiorse Ronan and Florence Pugh.

I never watch the Oscars, knowing my favourites are rarely nominated,let alone win. If anybody does something moving or controversial, I can watch it on YouTube later.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

biophile

59 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Most efed-up Oscar awards ever? [View all] Floyd R. Turbo Sunday OP

John Wayne was a terrible, terrible actor Orrex Sunday #1

And an asshole to boot! 🤬 Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #2

A bigot! BlueWaveNeverEnd Sunday #36

That too! Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #39

It was his last chance and Rooster Cogburn was iconic. Frasier Balzov Sunday #3

Bridges and the Cohen Brothers version were much closer to the book. I did like it more. And, Wayne did not deserve it! Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #6

It wasn't even his last chance to portray Rooster Cogburn. rsdsharp Sunday #12

We know that now. Frasier Balzov Sunday #17

His lung was removed in 1964. They were so afraid he might die that they waited five years? rsdsharp Sunday #18

Did he do anything Oscar worthy in the interim? Frasier Balzov Sunday #21

I didn't think he did anything Oscar worthy ever. rsdsharp Sunday #23

Deserved it? Iggo 17 hrs ago #56

It's possible most of the actor members of the Academy hated John Wayne's guts. Frasier Balzov 12 hrs ago #57

Rooster Cogburn was John Wayne with an eyepatch. Iggo 4 hrs ago #59

They should have given Marion Morrison the Oscar for one of his military roles. Aristus Sunday #4

As I said, "An asshole"! Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #7

Wayne wasnt a draft dodger. Thats an old urban legend. Callie1979 Sunday #11

World War II Marines had a different view. From author William Manchester: rsdsharp Sunday #13

A story which itself is questionable. Callie1979 Sunday #15

Oh? Did Manchester make it up? rsdsharp Sunday #16

Are there any Marines who were there to verify the story? Callie1979 Sunday #19

Wayne tried to join the naval academy in 1925, rsdsharp Sunday #22

Many Hollywood stars older than Wayne willingly served in WWII Wiz Imp Sunday #26

Thank you for posting this. Stewart was less than a year younger than Wayne. rsdsharp Sunday #32

Jimmy Stewart stayed in the AF reserves and ultimately achieved... 3catwoman3 20 hrs ago #49

I met a WWll bomber pilot from the squadron with the movie stars. Norrrm 19 hrs ago #53

my English grandfather was 38 when he spent the week on the beaches of Dunkirk Skittles Sunday #34

It's not rumors. It's fact. Just because you refuse to accept it and insist on making Wiz Imp Sunday #24

Not an urban legend at all. He was not "technically" or "legally" a draft dodger Wiz Imp Sunday #14

Ford had letters from Wayne asking him to let him enlist in his unit. Callie1979 Sunday #20

False. There is definite evidence he actively worked to avoid service. Wiz Imp Sunday #27

Proof shows he tried to enter the Naval Academy, enlist in the OSS & join Fords unit Callie1979 Sunday #37

Yes. Still, some of the most recent decades of top movie winners have really incredibly sucked... hlthe2b Sunday #5

Another reason to hate the asshole! Poor horses! 😢 Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #8

Maybe for the Best Actor award Fiendish Thingy Sunday #9

Haven't watched them in years! Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #40

Yip, and Peter 7 noms, no wins. When first offered an Honorary he turned it down saying UTUSN Sunday #10

Peter a class act! Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #41

that dreck Forrest Gump beating Pulp Fiction Skittles Sunday #25

I agree. MIButterfly Sunday #30

Don't get me started! 🤬 Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #42

right?! Skittles Sunday #46

Didn't I say don't get me started? Floyd R. Turbo Yesterday #47

LOL, I couldn't help myself Skittles 22 hrs ago #48

😁 Floyd R. Turbo 17 hrs ago #55

I thought Forrest Gump was one of the dumbest movies ever. 3catwoman3 20 hrs ago #50

I didn't make it past 15 minutes Skittles 20 hrs ago #51

Implausibility is one of the most important aspects of... GReedDiamond 9 hrs ago #58

There was a time that his schtick with women was considered funny ms liberty Sunday #28

Asshole! Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #43

Nicolas Cage, Leaving Las Vegas, 1996.. Permanut Sunday #29

Another one that pissed me off! Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #44

'99 "Shakespeare in Love" over "Saving Private Ryan" AND '93 Pacino as Best Actor underpants Sunday #31

"Scent of a Woman" was NOT Al Pacino's best performance by a long shot. MIButterfly Sunday #33

Absolutely. From Michael* to Serpico to Dog Day underpants Sunday #35

I HATED that movie...one of the worst I've seen! Totally Tunsie Sunday #38

Yep! Floyd R. Turbo Sunday #45

'True Shit" as we used to say Klarkashton 19 hrs ago #52

🤗 Floyd R. Turbo 17 hrs ago #54