Most religion is faith-based, rather than logic-based.

[TlalocW]

18. I have a jar of jellybeans

These are unique jellybeans that cannot be counted. Perhaps like Schrodinger's Cat, if you open the container, the wave form collapses, and the jelly beans disappear.

Someone with some sort of theism related to jellybeans says, "I believe the number of jellybeans is even."
The jellybean atheist says, "I have no reason to believe that."
Another jellybean theist who shares the same religion as the first but believes even numbers of jellybeans are an abomination says, "The number is odd."
The jellybean atheist says, "I have no reason to believe that."
Both theists are upset with the atheist because if he doesn't believe the other's claim, the atheist should be on his side then.
The atheist says, "I have no reason to believe the number is even or that the number is odd (though one must be true)."

Who is being the most logical?

TlalocW